Monday, 20 August 2018

A Monologue: Josephine Butler and the Contagious Diseases Act

Gardenias in January

You may wonder why I am here? Why is my dress torn, my hair and face blackened. Well the truth is that I escaped from a fire. I was addressing a crowd in a barn when my opponents set fire to it. I was on the upper floor speaking to my supporters. My enemies set fire to the ground floor but I managed to escape thankfully. The barn didn’t, it went up in smoke, you could see the blaze for miles. They might have thought they’d won that I was gone, but they were wrong, here I am and I can still tell the tale.

It’s a story about power and weakness, men, of course, have the power and they exercise it as they can. Women do not have the power and so they are weaker not in themselves as I can testify, but in the face of the law.

Do you know that a woman if she is found in the street with a man, dare I say it, who is not her husband, can be arrested, that’s right, arrested on the grounds that if she is not with her husband she must be a prostitute.

They call it The Contagious Diseases Act.  The politicians say that they passed the law to protect men.  As if men’s behaviour had nothing to do with it.  It was to protect soldiers in garrison towns at first. They thought that being men they needed sex, they needed to relieve themselves and better with a woman than each other.

But they didn’t want disease, venereal disease, to spread throughout the whole of the British Army, so it was decided to make sure that the women were clean.

So if a woman was going about her own business, walking down a street in Colchester or Newcastle upon Tyne or Edinburgh. If she  walking out with a man who was not her husband. Then she could be stopped by a policeman and arrested. She could be brought before a magistrate, also a man of course, who could demand that she was examined or face prison.


If she was examined by a Doctor, also a man whose poking and probing was highly intrusive, highly personal, her modesty was  swept away, her dignity was lost as she was examined for signs of venereal disease. rape by statute is what I call it.

If she was declared clean the decision to release her was made by a man, if not she would be forcibly held and remitted to the Bridewell, not to be treated you understand but to be punished, by men.

You might by now be asking how I a well raised gentlewoman from sweet Glendale in the shadow of the Cheviot Hills, came to be travelling the land from North to South, East to West in stagecoach and on carriage talking about this vile act and crusading as I call it to remove it entirely from the statute book because as I have argued, over and again it violates the constitutional rights of women as set out very clearly in the Magna Carta.

Why you might ask how the daughter of a gentleman and the wife of an Anglican Clergyman, both a Canon of a Winchester Cathedral and Headmaster of Liverpool College came to be speaking to senior clergy, politicians, schoolmasters, generals and whoever would listen, but especially and most importantly to working men and women whose own daughters were at risk from this vile act, about the morality of men.

I’m not saying that there isn’t problem with prostitution but sex is not a commodity to be bought and sold. And when a woman is forced to prostitute herself to feed her children, it is not the morality of women that is the only issue here.  It is also the morality of men as we have argued in newspaper articles and speeches.

I am so glad and grateful and so admiring of my gentle husband George who has supported me throughout my campaign at the risk of the wrath of his lords and masters in the Church of England and the abuse and scorn of his fellows including members of parliament who have demanded that he quietens and controls me, his wife. They wonder what drives me to campaign on behalf of other women less fortunate than myself.

Let me explain George was with me that awful day when our beloved Evangeline Mary died at our feet in the hallway of our house in Cheltenham, a house which had been a delightful family home until that terrible, terrible evening when we came home from the theatre.

So delighted was Eva to see her parents returning home after a pleasant evening that she ran forward on the upper landing of the house, she must have tripped, maybe over her skirt or her own dainty feet but as she came to the balustrade she toppled over and fell to our feet her skull smashed on the marble floor, her blood spilt and my tears spilt also mingling with her blood on the marble tiles of the hallway. She lasted a few brief hours before dying in my arms.

After the death of Evangeline Mary we could no longer remain in the house and before too long but not soon enough, George was appointed as Principal of Liverpool College and we were pleased to leave Cheltenham behind.

However the sad, sad memory of our lovely daughter Eva came with us. We grieved in our hearts and in our minds for the loss of such a lovely child and in time it seemed I needed to find a way of assuaging my grief. So I went out to find a grief keener than mine own in order for mine to become less.

What better place to find grief in all its forms than the Bridewell. Liverpool Bridewell is an imposing and grim place its hard exterior and meaner interior meant that for so many, especially women who had been arrested for vagrancy and prostitution, it was a place of final resort, beyond it lay nothing but death.

When I first visited the prison the Governor was shocked and felt that I might bring a little mercy and consolation to the women, but I needed more than mercy and consolation myself and so I asked if I could sit with the women at their work if work it can be called, slavery would be a more apt description of what these poor women were forced into.

Oakum is a tarry substance found in rope, once picked from the rope it is used to seal the hulls of ships. The rope is delivered to the women in the work room of the Bridewell, it is then untwisted, hard, difficult work, hard on fingers, hard on backs and unhealthy, hands become twisted and torn and filthy and hard to clean. The rope must be twisted until the Oakum is revealed and can then be pulled from the rope, it appears as a tarry corkscrew like material and when it is ready it is transported from the Bridewell to the shipyards where it is used to seal the hulls of ships making them watertight and seaworthy.

Here as I worked at this hard forced labour I began to hear the stories of the women with whom I was incarcerated. How they had been arrested. How they had become pregnant and lost a child. How they had been seduced by a wealthy man and then abandoned.

Yes it is a matter of morality of course but it is also in our society an issue of class for almost all of these tragic women were the daughters of working men, families with little money whose daughters went into service and who were vulnerable to their new masters whims, desires and advances.

I spent many dark days in the Bridewell and the memory of little Eva accompanied me and helped me as I came to terms with my grief and it was there that I met the woman who changed my life and gave me the heart for my great crusade to bring this vile law to an end and remove it entirely from the statute books.

Mary had been reduced by men’s iniquity to prostitution, seduced by the master of the house where she was in service and then having become pregnant thrown onto the streets without help or support she was imprisoned in the Bridewell until she became sick with consumption.

Having discussed her sadness with my dear husband it became clear that she should be welcomed into our house where she could rest and if not recover from her poor health at least die in comfort, amongst friends in clean sheets.

When the carriage carrying her from the Bridewell arrived at our door my dear husband descended the steps to the pavement, opened the door of her carriage and took her hand as though she were a great lady and welcome guest which of course she was.

Her last days were long and painful but as her health declined she became as though wrapt in the company of angels and spoke of her early days remembering her childhood with great pleasure and so, began to face her end with quiet dignity.

She died in January 1863 and George agreed when I suggested that as a mark of our respect and love and as a commitment to the campaign that must follow our earlier work of establishing a safe non judgemental house which we called an industrial home where the women we supported could re-establish their lives and move toward independence as free actors. We decided to fill her casket with white gardenias which we did whilst quietly weeping for Eva as we did so.

Once I embarked on my great crusade men’s opposition grew ever more violent and misogynistic I cannot began to tell you what we suffered as we went about the country speaking against this abuse of women and speaking for an improvement in the morality of men.

I spent most of the year 1870 travelling up and down the country 3,700 miles, the horses were fairy worn out I attended and spoke at almost a hundred meetings that year.

However badly the opposition behaved I could always count on working-class family men, who shared my outraged at the examination women their daughters, were forced to suffer it was as I repeatedly said rape, by statute, by surgery by cold steel wielded by men.

There were many attempts to dissuade me from following my heart and I was often in very real danger.

Of course the real opposition remained in the background, silent and menacing. They just hired others, petty hooligans and youths who for a few coppers would seek to disrupt our meetings.

I was no stranger to threats, abuse, words I barely knew thrown at me along with sticks and stones to break windows drown out my words even cow dung was thrown, I was no stranger to abuse.

 But I stayed with the campaign, George always supporting me as he could, and we have made progress, indeed only recently a great supporter of the act admitted to me that the manifesto has shaken members of the House of Commons very badly; he went on to admit that they thought they could manage any opposition in the House or in the country, but we have made it very awkward for them, a revolt of the women is it seem a new thing; and they are beginning to ask what are we to do with such an opposition as this?"

And why am I before you now like this, ragged and torn looking as though I have escaped from a firework party that went badly out of control.

I came to Morpeth only this evening and asked the Vicar if I could hold a rally in his Church or Church Hall at first he seemed to agree but it seems that others carry more influence than him either in the Church in indeed, in the town, and so he withdrew his offer leaving me without a place to speak or anywhere to attract the crowds we need.

I was saved by the good offices of a well respected working man of the town who introduced me to a spacious barn just outside the town where I could hold my rally in the upper floor, the lower floor being stocked with hay or straw.

I began to speak, describing the effects of this vile act, its impact on the lives of so many unfortunate women, its destruction of family life, the distress and misery it causes and why it violates the constitutional rights of men and women alike.

I was, as I always am, so impassioned as I spoke that I neither saw or heard the commotion that arose until I began to see smoke rising up through the floorboards into the chamber where I was speaking.

As so often it was not just those who seduce or rape young women or those who seek to avail themselves of the services of those forced into prostitution who sought to silence me, on this occasion it was the pimps, who pander to the customers to provide sex acts for them for monies.

They had overcome the gentlemen guarding the entry doorway and set fire to the ground floor which quickly took hold and spread, burning the ladders leading up to the upper story and trapping both myself and the crowd and condemning us to death. Fortunately there there present good working folk who kept their heads about them and so many of the crowd myself included were lowered through upper windows to the ground below and made our escape.

And so I survive again to tell my story, pursue my campaign on behalf of young women who have no voice, no means to survive and fall foul of men’s immorality.

I am, and always have been uncompromising about this vile act since I picked oakum in the Bridewell.  The state regulation of contagious diseases enslaves and disenfranchises women for the benefit of men, who then make the laws that punish women whom they have enslaved and disenfranchised.

This must end and it must end now.





Saturday, 18 August 2018

The Brexit of Fear and the loss of hope ......

Whilst I have always enjoyed visiting new countries, and as a one time regular commuter to Belgium, old countries again and again, I have always felt proud to be British.

Now I am not so sure.

After the Dave and George show ended with resignation and the  election of a new Prime Minister there was a brief moment of hope that Matron would spank a few bottoms, send everyone off to bed early without supper and then set about ensuring that the things were put right and that Rees Mogg's nanny scolded him and told him to wise up.

But it wasn't to be.

Instead she went from remainer to brexiteer, and immediately gave notice that we wanted out ASAP and the rest of Europe just had to put up with it.

Indeed their loss would be our gain.

But that is not the outcome that we can now foresee. Indeed our loss is beginning to prove to be their gain.

And the fears that led to brexit are very tangible and still with us.

A colleague of mine once suggested that the then newly opened Nissan factory in Sunderland would fail because the British would not accept Japanese working practices, after all he said, with our climate we cannot live in paper houses and we wouldn't wish to.

Yet despite the fact that he was wrong, despite the success of the factory, its competitiveness and the fact that the majority of cars made there are sold into Europe, Sunderland cast its vote with leave.com, UKIP and Mr Farage (which google auto correct ironically interprets as garage) and voted leave.

It is difficult to understand how this happened.

One explanation is fear. Fear of the 'other' outweighing the fear of the consequences of the actions we take.

So immigration clearly tops our list of fears, those 'others', who come from a wide variety of places across Europe, Africa and Asia to make their homes here with us in this land of opportunity we call home. For many people in the UK the impact of immigration is positive. Whether in culture, in the arts, in music or in food we are treated to a richness of experience that broadens our horizons, enriches our day to day experience and whilst at times it might challenge us, it does not and cannot harm us.

Immigration is meant to have a negative impact on Jobs, Housing and Benefits but despite the tabloid headlines the facts, that is to say tedious, complex, boring statistics suggest otherwise. When employment in service industries is taken into account the reliance of our economy on workers from Europe, Africa and Asia cannot be underestimated or undervalued.

As we are beginning to see the NHS alone of our caring agencies is dependant on workers from other parts of the world. Any visit to an A&E, any stay in hospital, any visit to a GP's surgery will remind us of how much we rely on immigration and how indebted we are to those professional people who come from other parts of the world to live and work in the UK.

The debate of course rages. Planes my be grounded, the M20 become a linear car park, the boats might not dock at Dover. Goods may never arrive. The Post may grind to a halt. Amazon may stop delivering next day. Lives may be rendered more uncomfortable. No-one really knows and the arguments swing backwards and forwards without resolution.

If the worst case scenario does not happen all may be well after a fashion but there may well not be best case scenario, simply because that is what after forty years we have already in our membership of the EU.

I am about to head off to Europe to work.

I have medical cover through my E11, I have insurance, I am allowed to ply my trade, I have my boarding card and I have my passport. When I arrive at my destination however I will not be an, albeit temporary immigrant, I will be an ex pat, that is to say I will be someone temporarily (or permanently) living in a country other than my native country.

However, after March 19th 2019 all that might change, if the brexit of fear is ushered in with the wild whooping of Rees Moggs, Johnsons and Farages and their supporters then both those ex pats who come here and those ex pats who go here there and everywhere will experience the loss of hope as their lives, their opportunities, their welfare and their well being is reduced.

It seems to me from what I read that the penny is slowly beginning to drop, time is short, Dave is locked in a shepherds hut writing his  memoirs which I look forward to reading when I pick up a copy in the charity shop, we are left only with Nanny who is yet to smack the bottoms that need smacking.